Were Liverpool’s Salah and Van Dijk renewals two of the most expensive mistakes in football history?
Samuel Bannister Were Salah and Van Dijk's new deals mistakes?
Amid the small matter of a Premier League title challenge, last season’s Liverpool news was dominated by the fate of the three key players approaching the end of their contracts.
If you had told those of a Liverpool persuasion that they would keep two out of three, your premonition would have been met with positivity. The two that remained – Mohamed Salah and Virgil van Dijk – have become bona fide Liverpool legends since their arrivals in 2017 and 2018.
By the time they finally signed their latest Liverpool contracts, Salah and Van Dijk were both in their thirties. Nevertheless, the club handed them two of the most lucrative contracts that have ever been gifted to Premier League players.
Salah’s deal is said to be worth £400,000 per week, with another £100,000 in bonuses. Van Dijk reportedly earns £350,000 per week, with another £50,000 in bonuses. The only consolation is that clearly not too many bonus measures have been met.
They are the second and third highest-paid players in the Premier League, behind only Erling Haaland, the player who scored a hat-trick against Liverpool in the FA Cup quarter-final on Saturday.
In contrast, Salah and Van Dijk are nowhere close to providing good value for money compared to the generous investment made by the club.
Liverpool and Salah have already decided to go their separate ways this summer after what is almost certain to be the lowest-scoring season of his spell with the club. It’s a decision they could even have made in January after?thatinterview.
For Van Dijk, there will be one more year of contract remaining at Anfield. Guilty of giving a penalty away against City, it would take some redemption arc for him to rediscover form worthy of the league’s best-paid defender.
So did Liverpool make a mistake giving those flashy contracts to Salah and Van Dijk in the first place?
When they were on course to winning the Premier League, there was little reason not to keep two of their key players. But giving themthosesalaries exudes a sense of short-termism, not forecasting the inevitable declines of two players far nearer the end of their careers than the start. And Liverpool are now paying a hefty price.
That’s not to say Salah and Van Dijk are solely to blame for their feeble title defence. Their performance levels have dropped this season, but so have some of their teammates. New signings haven’t had the impact expected of them; their manager has struggled to find an effective formula.
But the two renewals now look like costly mistakes, with echoes of when Arsenal gave lucrative new contracts to Mesut Ozil and Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang before having to rip up those new deals after their deterioration and inevitable inability to attract any buyers.
Ozil and Aubameyang were brilliant when at their best, but Arsenal reached a point where they were starting to hold them back and they had to move on.
Liverpool themselves will now let Salah move to a new club for free in the summer, nearly three years after rejecting a £150m package from Al-Ittihad. For the last year of his contract, they will have spent more than £20m on his wages, while spending more than £18m on Van Dijk’s. Their best player this season, Dominik Szoboszlai, has cost them about a third of Van Dijk.
It’s hard to look at Liverpool’s renewals of Salah and Van Dijk and not think they got something wrong. Keeping them wasn’t the mistake; giving them those terms absolutely was. It’s the kind of schoolboy error we expect of Manchester United, not Liverpool.
There have been bigger wastes of money in football. Expensive signings who flopped, players on big salaries who became injury prone. The business Liverpool conducted for Salah and Van Dijk – all before a summer in which they broke their transfer record twice – was not the worst ever witnessed, but there should certainly be questions asked as Liverpool stare at a £39m cost for a rotten double of a season.
READ MORE: Who will be the next manager of Liverpool after Arne Slot exit?
F365 Says Mohamed Salah
Related Articles
Jason Soutar
Trademark Arsenal bore us to death but win again thanks to Raya and Havertz
Arsenal beat Sporting thanks to Kai Havertz’s late winner, but it was another excruciating watch in a 2025/26 season full of them.
F365 Says Popular Matt Stead
Ferdinand retirement prevents ‘Ballon d’Or’ 90-minute soundtrack to Real Madrid 1-2 Bayern
The Champions League quarter final between Real Madrid and Bayern Munich was wonderful entertainment thankfully not spoiled by Rio Ferdinand.
F365 Says Harry Kane Rob McCarthy
Arne Slot responds to Van Dijk, Liverpool ‘quit’ remarks as Isak return confirmed
The Reds are gearing up to face PSG in the Champions League, off the back of the FA Cup debacle at City, in a game that should see the return ...
Liverpool Alexander Isak Ian Watson
Premier League predicted final table: Spurs doomed as De Zerbi’s task is laid bare
For the Tottenham Hotspur fans looking for reasons to be cheerful about their club’s predicament, we bring good news: Lincoln is lovely in winter…
F365 Features Popular Editor F365
Slot ‘performed miracle’ with ‘ageing team’ and is not ‘getting the credit he deserves’ at Liverpool
The idea Liverpool should sack Arne Slot is rubbished by one writer who believes the Dutchman ‘performed a miracle’ with an ‘ageing team’.
Mediawatch Arne Slot Joe Williams
‘Very few out there’ – Steven Gerrard tells Liverpool to make perfect summer signing
Liverpool legend Steven Gerrard hopes the Reds can go and replace Mohamed Salah with Michael Olise in the summer transfer window.
Liverpool Michael Olise
Latest Football News
Arne Slot responds to Van Dijk, Liverpool ‘quit’ remarks as Isak return confirmed
Alexander Isak Arne Slot
Man Utd, Man City target Elliot Anderson makes transfer decision with ‘race won’ for £65m signing
Elliot Anderson
Newcastle sent ‘relegation’ warning amid Howe ‘doubts’ as Magpies star makes ‘decision on next move’
Eddie Howe Kieran Trippier
Spurs: Dyche reveals two reasons why ‘no amount of money’ would have tempted him to accept job
Sean Dyche
Arsenal told one club will stop them winning the Champions League – ‘I’d edge towards them’
Gareth Barry Paris Saint-Germain Mailbox
‘Unwatchable’ Arsenal have made neutrals support Man City
‘Pathetic’ Arsenal are handing domestic Treble to Manchester City
Mikel Arteta Popular
Arsenal ‘bottlemageddon’ continues as Liverpool should give Slot a statue… then sack him
Arne Slot Mikel Arteta
‘Wet wipe’ Steven Gerrard and his ‘neck’ are destroyed
Popular Steven Gerrard Premier League Table Full Table
#
TEAM
P
W
D
L
GD
PTS
View More
Mediawatch
Slot ‘performed miracle’ with ‘ageing team’ and is not ‘getting the credit he deserves’ at Liverpool
Arne Slot Popular
England doomed to more World Cup quarter-final woe as ‘Arsenal star’ warns of ‘car crash’
De Zerbi ‘cancelled’ despite £60m Spurs agreement after ‘choosing not to exclude Greenwood’
Popular Roberto De Zerbi
Manchester United receive questionable ‘transfer boost’ over Tonali – and Spurs are ‘too good for’ De Zerbi
Copyright Notice: The content of this article is contributed by Internet users. The views only represent the author. This site only provides information storage services and does not own ownership or bear relevant legal responsibilities. If you find any suspected infringement or illegal content, please contact us. We will delete it immediately after verification.