Man Utd better than Arsenal under Carrick as Red Devils face dilemma
Ian Watson Casemiro is enjoying his football under Michael Carrick at Manchester United.
Manchester United have taken more points than any other club since Michael Carrick took charge, which presents a dilemma for the Red Devils…
Following the sacking of Ruben Amorim and a brief handover spell for Darren Fletcher, Carrick was placed in interim charge on January 12, with United seventh.
They were in touch with the Champions League places, thanks largely to the failings of others.
And when United had the opportunities to climb into the top four, it was a hurdle they could not get over.
As much as United were pretending to look up, they were only a bad weekend from the bottom half too.
Here is where Carrick found United…
PREMIER LEAGUE TABLE ON JANUARY 13, 2026
It is worth highlighting the gap between United and Aston Villa. Carrick was looking at an 11-point chasm between themselves and Unai Emery’s side.
But United have reined Villa in and put a seven-point gap between themselves and sixth-placed Chelsea.
They have done that by taking more points than any other club in the 10 games Carrick has been in charge.
PREMIER LEAGUE TABLE SINCE CARRICK TOOK OVER
Why is that a problem? Because it gives the Old Trafford hierarchy a dilemma they almost certainly were not anticipating.
When they hired Carrick, it was on the understanding that this was very much an interim arrangement before the appointment of a ‘proper’ manager.
MORE: Keane: ‘I think there are better options than Carrick’
However, if United maintain their form between now and the end of the season, perhaps even closing the gap to second place, does Carrick not merit the permanent job?
Hiring him permanently would be a risk, given the doubts around his pedigree and – weirdly – his ‘charisma’. But showing him the door to hire a bigger name with no guarantee of the success Carrick has prompted so far would also be viewed as a gamble.
What should United do?
F365 Features Michael Carrick
Related Articles
Jason Soutar
Trademark Arsenal bore us to death but win again thanks to Raya and Havertz
Arsenal beat Sporting thanks to Kai Havertz’s late winner, but it was another excruciating watch in a 2025/26 season full of them.
F365 Says Popular Matt Stead
Ferdinand retirement prevents ‘Ballon d’Or’ 90-minute soundtrack to Real Madrid 1-2 Bayern
The Champions League quarter final between Real Madrid and Bayern Munich was wonderful entertainment thankfully not spoiled by Rio Ferdinand.
F365 Says Harry Kane Lewis Oldham
Man Utd: Butt names ‘easy choice’ to be next permanent manager as Scholes raises ‘big’ Carrick concern
Ex-Manchester United star Nicky Butt thinks INEOS have an “easy choice” regarding their next permanent manager.
Manchester United Michael Carrick Ian Watson
Premier League predicted final table: Spurs doomed as De Zerbi’s task is laid bare
For the Tottenham Hotspur fans looking for reasons to be cheerful about their club’s predicament, we bring good news: Lincoln is lovely in winter…
F365 Features Popular Editor F365
Slot ‘performed miracle’ with ‘ageing team’ and is not ‘getting the credit he deserves’ at Liverpool
The idea Liverpool should sack Arne Slot is rubbished by one writer who believes the Dutchman ‘performed a miracle’ with an ‘ageing team’.
Mediawatch Arne Slot Joe Williams
Man Utd identify £74m duo as they look to make ‘decisive move’ after one deal is officially confirmed
Man Utd have identified Nico Schlotterbeck and Maghnes Akliouche as two of their top targets for the summer, according to reports.
Manchester United Michael Carrick
Latest Football News
Arne Slot responds to Van Dijk, Liverpool ‘quit’ remarks as Isak return confirmed
Alexander Isak Arne Slot
Man Utd, Man City target Elliot Anderson makes transfer decision with ‘race won’ for £65m signing
Elliot Anderson
Newcastle sent ‘relegation’ warning amid Howe ‘doubts’ as Magpies star makes ‘decision on next move’
Eddie Howe Kieran Trippier
Spurs: Dyche reveals two reasons why ‘no amount of money’ would have tempted him to accept job
Sean Dyche
Arsenal told one club will stop them winning the Champions League – ‘I’d edge towards them’
Gareth Barry Paris Saint-Germain Mailbox
‘Unwatchable’ Arsenal have made neutrals support Man City
‘Pathetic’ Arsenal are handing domestic Treble to Manchester City
Mikel Arteta Popular
Arsenal ‘bottlemageddon’ continues as Liverpool should give Slot a statue… then sack him
Arne Slot Mikel Arteta
‘Wet wipe’ Steven Gerrard and his ‘neck’ are destroyed
Popular Steven Gerrard Premier League Table Full Table
#
TEAM
P
W
D
L
GD
PTS
View More
Mediawatch
Slot ‘performed miracle’ with ‘ageing team’ and is not ‘getting the credit he deserves’ at Liverpool
Arne Slot Popular
England doomed to more World Cup quarter-final woe as ‘Arsenal star’ warns of ‘car crash’
De Zerbi ‘cancelled’ despite £60m Spurs agreement after ‘choosing not to exclude Greenwood’
Popular Roberto De Zerbi
Manchester United receive questionable ‘transfer boost’ over Tonali – and Spurs are ‘too good for’ De Zerbi
Copyright Notice: The content of this article is contributed by Internet users. The views only represent the author. This site only provides information storage services and does not own ownership or bear relevant legal responsibilities. If you find any suspected infringement or illegal content, please contact us. We will delete it immediately after verification.